Neurotensin (NT) exerts its analgesic effects through activation of the G protein-coupled receptors NTS1 and NTS2. This opioid-independent antinociception represents a potential alternative for pain management. While activation of NTS1 also induces a drop in blood pressure and body temperature, NTS2 appears to be an analgesic target free of these adverse effects. Here, we report modifications of NT at Tyr11 to increase selectivity toward NTS2, complemented by modifications at the N-terminus to impair proteolytic degradation of the biologically active NT(8–13) sequence. Replacement of Tyr11by either 6-OH-Tic or 7-OH-Tic resulted in a significant loss of binding affinity to NTS1 and subsequent NTS2 selectivity. Incorporation of the unnatural amino acid β3hLys at position 8 increased the half-life to over 24 h in plasma. Simultaneous integration of both β3hLys8 and 6-OH-Tic11 into NT(8–13) produced a potent and NTS2-selective analogue with strong analgesic action after intrathecal delivery in the rat formalin-induced pain model with an ED50 of 1.4 nmol. Additionally, intravenous administration of this NT analogue did not produce persistent hypotension or hypothermia. These results demonstrate that NT analogues harboring unnatural amino acids at positions 8 and 11 can enhance crucial pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic features for NT(8–13) analogues, i.e., proteolytic stability, NTS2 selectivity, and improved analgesic/adverse effect ratio.